| Peter Pan | Corrie Ehrhart |
| Wendy Darling | Elizabeth White |
| John Darling | Cameron Null |
| Liza, the maid | Mallory Ehrhart |
| Michael Darling | Luke Eicher |
| Mrs. Darling | Jennifer Thomas |
| Mr. Darling | Rob Young |
| Slightly | Leah Thomas |
| Tootles | Michael Gallup |
| Curly | Trey McFarland |
| Nibs | Kaden Kennedy |
| 1st Twin | Bri Young |
| 2nd Twin | Natalie Wakefield |
| Captain Hook | Rob Young |
| Smee | Spencer Sells |
| Tiger Lily | Triniti McFarland |
| Wendy (as a grown up lady) | Jennifer Thomas |
| Jane, Wendy’s Daughter | Emma Huber-Whitman |
| Pirates: | |
| Dennis Jackson | |
| Colton Hancock | |
| Jarred Miller | |
| Titus Garmater | |
| Crystal Brooke | |
| Jeff Rumple | |
| Kris Rumple | |
| Terina Wakefield | |
| Ensemble: Indians and Lost Boys | |
| Lydia Sullivan | |
| Sabrina Ramey | |
| Amber Sigman | |
| Julianna Berger | |
| Jillian Miller | |
| Avery Miller | |
| Olivaia Spangle | |
| Laynee Wright | |
| Leah Garmater | |
| Nathan Boyer | |
| Kate Farr | |
| Aleyah Mack | |
| Madison Smith | |
| Alexandra Lehman | |
| Emily Stuck | |
| Myranda Brooks | |
| Aniyah Sajvan | |
